This 2015 Honda Civic LX came in from Newmarket with 189,000 kilometres and was in average overall condition, with an accident history exceeding $8,000 along with minor rusting and cosmetic damage.
At this mileage level, many buyers begin to apply more conservative pricing, and when accident history is involved, that reduction often becomes more aggressive.
Despite that, vehicles like the Civic continue to perform well. Known for reliability and strong long-term use, they remain one of the most in-demand daily drivers, even with higher kilometres and past damage.
When comparing offers, the difference came down to how the accident history was evaluated. Some buyers discounted heavily based on the claim alone, while others focused on the full picture — including demand, usability, and the vehicle’s overall condition.
That difference resulted in a significantly stronger final offer.